Times Comedians Played TV Villains (And Nailed It)

Julian Hoffman
Updated January 1, 2025 15 items
Ranked By
1.1K votes
274 voters
Voting Rules
Vote up the most brilliant performances.

Some actors who played iconic villains on TV weren't always the most obvious choice. Some of the best TV villains of all time have been portrayed by actors with a background in comedy, or even by straight-up stand-up comedians. Comedians often have an easier time putting themselves out there due to the over-critical nature of comedy and often come out with some of the boldest performances on television. In this list, we note the best TV villains that were played by normally comedic actors and why they nailed it. 

Warning: Spoilers to follow.


  • Bryan Cranston As Walter White In 'Breaking Bad'

    Bryan Cranston might just be the most notable case of a former comedic actor breaking through with a major dramatic role. Starting off as a humble family man, Walter White eventually spiraled into a murderous, meth-dealing criminal who lost sight of everything that mattered in his life. Walter White's descent from hero to villain is one of TV's greatest performances, which is still largely unmatched to this day. 

    Cranston previously had been known for playing Hal Wilkerson on Malcolm in the Middle and guest-starring on various sitcoms such as Seinfeld and How I Met Your Mother. It wasn't until Breaking Bad that Cranston would be recognized as a serious dramatic actor and the recipient of just about every acting award there is. 

    181 votes
    Brilliant performance?
  • John Lithgow As Arthur Mitchell In 'Dexter'

    John Lithgow has been acting since the 1970s but you may remember him most from his role as Dr. Dick Soloman on the sitcom 3rd Rock From The Sun or as Lord Farquaad in Shrek. By the late 1990s / 2000s, the prolific actor had opted for predominantly comedic roles, until he emerged as Arthur Mitchell a.k.a. The Trinity Killer in the fourth season of Dexter

    The Trinity Killer was the alter ego of Arthur Mitchell, a seemingly normal family man who you'd never guess had brutally killed nearly 300 people in his 30-year tenure as the enigmatic serial killer. Lithgow was the perfect choice to play Mitchell due to his inherently comical and gentle demeanor, making Arthur Mitchell a truly unassuming psychopath. 

    127 votes
    Brilliant performance?
  • Katey Sagal As Gemma Teller In 'Sons Of Anarchy'

    Before playing Gemma Teller in Sons of Anarchy, Katey Sagal was known for her roles in Married... with Children, 8 Simple Rules, and Futurama. Suffice to say, Sagal went through her fair share of sitcoms before eventually landing arguably the best role of her career, which was a bit of a step in the opposite direction, based on her previous work. 

    Though Gemma Teller wasn't that far out of her wheelhouse, (she was used to playing overbearing mothers) Sagal was surprisingly natural at portraying the den mother of a biker gang and all the criminal activities that come with it. Gemma later becomes a primary antagonist in the series, showcasing Sagal's talents at playing the morally conflicted but loving character. 

    116 votes
    Brilliant performance?
  • Bob Odenkirk As Saul Goodman In 'Breaking Bad' / 'Better Call Saul'
    • Photo:
      • Better Call Saul
      • AMC

    Although Saul Goodman might not appear like an outright villain, it would be sincerely wrong to classify him as anything else. Saul is a conniving, morally bankrupt, self-serving criminal who aids in the distribution of methamphetamine and is an accomplice to murder. So yes, he's definitely a villain but he also happens to be our favorite character thanks to Bob Odenkirk's hilarious portrayal of the greasy lawyer. 

    Before Saul, Odenkirk was known for his sketch comedy (alongside David Cross) and his various guest roles on sitcoms such as Curb Your Enthusiasm, Arrested Development, The Larry Sanders Show, and Seinfeld. It wasn't until Vince Gilligan offered him the role of Saul Goodman that Odenkirk was able to flex his acting chops and create a character that has now garnered more screentime than Walter White, having his own 6 season spin-off series. 

    101 votes
    Brilliant performance?
  • Michael McKean As Chuck McGill In 'Better Call Saul'

    Michael McKean, another Saturday Night Live and This Is Spinal Tap alumni, got his start as Lenny Kosnowski, the annoying neighbor on the Happy Days spin-off, Laverne & Shirley. Although he's had a long and prolific career in comedy, McKean began to receive critical recognition for his role as Chuck McGill on yet another spin-off series, Better Call Saul

    Chuck served as the main antagonist on Better Call Saul for the first three seasons of the show. He played Saul Goodman's smart but highly eccentric older brother who wanted nothing but to see Saul fail in the world of law. Chuck was not the kind of villain that Breaking Bad fans were accustomed to and brought some new and interesting aspects to the spin-off, proving once again that comedy actors can excel in dramatic roles. 

    55 votes
    Brilliant performance?
  • Bill Hader As Barry In 'Barry'

    It's hard not to think of Saturday Night Live when watching Bill Hader on screen. Hader's sketch and improv comedy is such an integral part of his career that he doesn't get enough credit for his actual acting work. Although he dipped into the "dramedy" world with films like Trainwreck and The Skeleton Twins, nothing could prepare us for his role as Barry in the eponymous HBO sitcom. 

    Barry is a (very) dark comedy series about a merciless hitman who aches to become an actor and put his murderous past behind him. Sadly, transitioning out of the "murder for hire" business and into show business is not a very realistic goal. Hader's performance as the anguished, tired assassin may just be the best of his career and an indication that he's more than capable of operating outside his comfort zone. 

    69 votes
    Brilliant performance?